View this artwork by appointment, at Tate Britain's Prints and Drawings Rooms
The Twickenham house of the poet Alexander Pope, remodelled as a villa by James Gibbs in 1720 and surrounded by gardens designed by the poet himself, was demolished in 1807 on the orders of Baroness Howe, who built another house nearby. She left only its most famous feature, the grotto in the basement of the villa, and stripped the grounds. Turner was distressed by such vandalism against the memory of a poet so strongly associated with the Thames-side landscape and one who had influenced his own literary efforts. As a Pastoral poet he even likened Pope to Virgil, calling him the ‘British Maro’.1
Here, from a position down-river, Turner has drawn the house partly dismantled but still showing traces of the wings added by Sir William Stanhope in the 1750s. The sketch served as the basis for his commemorative picture, Pope’s Villa at Twickenham, During its Dilapidation, shown at his own gallery in 1808 (on the London art market, 2008).2 Turner set up an impromptu studio in the summer-house of his Hammersmith house, and perhaps Pope’s Villa was painted there as the sketchbook was in use during visits. Butlin and Joll do not mention this drawing as its source, but quote the account of the 1808 exhibition in the Review of Publications of Art, possibly by John Landseer, stating that the view is ‘from the Middlesex bank of the river, or perhaps (as we conjecture) from one of the Twickenham aits: probably that which lies off the grounds of Strawberry Hill’.3
A fallen tree in the foreground of this drawing also appears in the painting, where it symbolises the weeping willow – one of the first to be imported into England – planted by Pope but later blown down in a storm as if as a portent of the destruction to come. When, subsequently, John Britton composed commentary for the engraving of the picture by John Pye and Charles Heath for his anthology Fine Arts of the English School, and chose to identify the willow as the one planted by the poet, Turner reined him in; ‘making the willow tree the identical Pope’s willow is rather strained – cannot you do it by allusion?’.4 Thus corrected, Britton’s published letterpress stated only that ‘in strict accordance with the subject, is the prostrate trunk of a willow tree’.
Wilton and Mallord Turner 1990, p.50
Martin Butlin and Evelyn Joll, The Paintings of J.M.W. Turner, revised ed., New Haven and London 1984, pp.55–6 no.72 (pl.82); Sotheby’s sale, 9 July 2008, lot 91.
Turner to John Britton, November 1811, in John Gage ed., Collected Correspondence of J.M.W. Turner, Oxford 1980, pp.50–1 no.43.
For further discussion see Wilton and Mallord Turner 1990, pp.50–3, 129–30.
You might like
After Joseph Mallord William Turner Pope’s Villa, engraved by Pye and Heath