 |
Room 9 - The Art of Illusion
Holbein’s portraits were celebrated in their own time
for the illusion they offer of the presence of the sitter.
Renaissance humanists compared contemporary artists to
the great artists of the classical past who had supposedly
confused humans, and even animals and insects, into
thinking their works were real objects. Holbein offered
ample opportunity for such praise with his ability to depict
likeness, texture, light and stillness in a manner that was
admirable and deceptive. This is especially forceful in
those portraits, many from the latter part of his career, in
which the subjects are presented in full-face to the viewer.
Convincing in detail and unflinching in the presentation
of old age, Holbein’s presentation of the sitters is
nevertheless tightly controlled. The size of the features
is sometimes exaggerated, and the space the subjects
occupy is limited, making them appear closer to us.
This sensation is heightened by the way in which in the
smaller, late portraits Holbein devotes more of the picture
surface to the head. Above all Holbein’s portraits are still:
gesture or movement could too easily seem arrested,
spoiling the illusion of presence. The paintings seem to
pivot between acknowledging the spell of their subjects
and the power of their creator.
From the Latin inscription on the portrait of Derich Born, 1533:
‘Add but the voice and you would wonder if his father or the painter created him’
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
Christina of Denmark, Duchess of Milan (1538)
Lent by The National Gallery, London. Presented by The Art Fund
with the aid of an anonymous donation, 1909
Oil on oak
1791 x 826 mm
enlarge this image
Holbein was sent to Brussels in March 1538 to
take the portrait of the sixteen year-old Christina,
a prospective bride for Henry VIII. The King was
insistent on informative portraits, and Holbein has
ensured that Christina’s face and hands are clearly
presented against her widow’s black.
The placing of her shadow on the left, the strong
vertical shadow to the right and the suppression
of further spatial information all subtly serve to
propel her figure towards the viewer, as if in
seductive motion.
Listen to the audio guide clip for this work
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
Derich Born (dated 1533)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Oil on panel
603 x 451 mm
Derich Born (1509/10 – after 1549) was a
Hanseatic merchant from Cologne. The Latin
inscription asserts that if a voice was added the
picture would seem to be Derich himself and that
it is doubtful whether the painter or the subject’s
father produced the image – that is, whether this
is the real Derich or simply a picture.
Born is positioned as though to challenge the
viewer in a confident frontal pose, his body
swivelled, his chin lined up with the point of
his elbow.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
An Unknown Man (about 1540)
Lent by English Heritage (Audley End). Purchased with the
assistance of the Heritage Lottery Fund
Oil on panel
444 x 342 mm
The portrait offers few clues as to the identity
of the sitter but his high-necked shirt and short
hair suggest it was painted in the latter part of
Holbein’s career in England, around 1540.
The near-frontal composition appears to centre
on the line of the white cuff of the left hand,
which aligns with the inner corner of the left eye.
The gloves were painted over the black coat,
suggesting they were a late addition; the fingers
were then slightly adjusted to accommodate this.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
An Unidentified Man (about 1535)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Black and coloured chalks and pen and ink and
brush on pink prepared paper
275 x 211 mm
The chalk modelling of this drawing is extensive,
particularly around the eyes, where it evokes
deeply recessed eye sockets. But Holbein has also
used ink with both pen and brush. He makes bold
use of an ink wash to evoke light and shade on
the hat and to suggest clumps of hair on the right,
while delineating very fine curling wisps of hair
which stand out against the background on the
left and can be seen in the beard. The notes on
the costume seem to record textures of satin and
velvet rather than colour (though S may stand for
‘schwarz’, black).
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
?Mary Zouch (about 1538)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Black and coloured chalks with pen and ink
on pink prepared paper
296 x 212 mm
The sitter may be the daughter of Lord Zouch,
who begged to run away because she was illtreated
by her stepmother and became Lady-in-
Waiting to Jane Seymour, or she may be Anne
Gainsford, Lady-in-Waiting to Anne Boleyn who
married George Zouche of Codnor; in that case
the inscription would indicate a ‘Mistress Zouch’.
Holbein used the full frontal view for the portraits
Henry VIII required of his potential brides in order
to make sure no defect escaped him, and possibly
this portrait too might have been intended as a
marriage portrait.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
An Unidentified Woman (about 1540)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Black and coloured chalks, pen and ink and brush
and white bodycolour on pink prepared paper
271 x 169 mm
The drawing has been cut out along its outlines
and stuck to another sheet of paper by a later
owner. However, much of the effect of the drawing
remains. The sitter’s glinting brown eyes are
worked up in unusual detail with a variety of
media: her pupils have catch-lights, her irises
show clearly the radiating muscles and her lower
eyelids are particularly prominent. Her very long
and minutely observed eyebrows are also drawn
with ink in great detail. By contrast Holbein is
economical in showing a single pattern repeat
for the embroidery of her collar.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
Lady Butts (about 1541–3)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Black and coloured chalks and metalpoint and
pen and brush and ink on pink prepared paper
380 x 273 mm
Margaret Bacon, Lady Butts, was the wife of
Sir William Butts (about 1485–1545), the royal
physician portrayed in the Barber-Surgeons
portrait (Room 7). She wears a carnation-like
flower on her dress.
The drawing is unsparing in the delineation of
Lady Butts’ wrinkles. According to the portrait
made after this drawing (Isabella Stewart Gardner
Museum, Boston) she was aged fifty seven.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
Thomas Howard, 3rd Duke of Norfolk (about 1539)
Lent by Her Majesty The Queen
Oil on oak
803 x 616 mm
The Duke of Norfolk (1473–1554) held a succession
of high posts at Henry VIII’s court: in this portrait
of about 1539 he carries the white staff of Lord
High Treasurer and the gold baton of Earl Marshal
as well as wearing the Order of the Garter.
Norfolk was the father of the poet Earl of Surrey
(Room 2), and both were imprisoned for treason
in 1546, but only Norfolk escaped execution.
The Duke, said to be ‘small and spare of stature’,
appears broad and imposing as he stands in this
three-quarter length portrait, a format Holbein
used only rarely.
|
|
Hans Holbein the Younger (1497/8–1543)
Dr John Chambers (about 1541–2)
Lent by the Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, Gemäldegalerie
Oil on oak
510 x 440 mm
Dr Chambers or Chamber (1470–1549) was a cleric
and physician to Henry VIII, one of the founders of
the Royal College of Physicians in 1518, and dean
of St Stephen’s Westminster.
Dr Chambers is shown on the left of the
Barber-Surgeons portrait (Room 7). This portrait
is adapted from that image: Chambers’ upward
glance there was adjusted so that he looks
straight ahead, and the hands gripping the gloves
were added.
The age recorded on the portrait is evidently
incorrect.
|
|  |
|