Eric Shanes has suggested that this colour study, along with Tate D25283
(Turner Bequest CCLXIII 161, 162, 188), is for an undeveloped view of Buckingham Palace in central London for Turner’s Picturesque Views in England and Wales
As he notes, the building ‘sported a dome for a short time in the 1820s’,2
when the former Buckingham House was redeveloped in palatial, classical style by John Nash (1752–1832) for King George IV (1820–1830).3
There are engravings made around 1830 showing the palace in this intermediate state: The Garden Front of the King’s Palace in Pimlico
from the west, across the lake in its gardens, by Thomas Higham (1796–1844), and The King’s Palace, Pimlico
from the east, across the lake in St James’s Park, after Thomas Hosmer Shepherd (1793–1864) (both London Metropolitan Archives). The engraving from the west in particular shows the central dome and four flanking rectangular attic pavilions; the latter were presumably demolished when the dome was replaced by the present central rectangular attic floor before 1847.4
Turner had recorded the west side of Buckingham House and its gardens before its aggrandisement in a panoramic drawing made in the late 1810s from the adjacent London home of his Yorkshire patron and friend and Walter Fawkes, in the Skies
sketchbook (Tate D12523
, Tate D12524
; Turner Bequest CLVIII 67a–68), the basis of the watercolour London, from the Windows of 45 Grosvenor Place
of about 1819 (private collection),5
but there are no identified sketches of the palace as such.
The three other colour studies mentioned at the beginning of this entry focus on the silhouette of a building with a central dome and flanking rectangular projections on the skyline, which correlate fairly well with Nash’s design, though it has previously been suggested that they may represent Hampton Court Palace from the Thames. Here the building is less prominent in the distance on the left, although its profile and its reflection do seem to indicate a central dome with rooftop projections either side. It has been catalogued and exhibited with generic titles such as ‘An Italian Landscape’ and ‘Two Trees in a Landscape’, and shows a general debt the serene, light-filled classical landscapes of Claude Lorrain (1604/5–1682) so admired and so often emulated by Turner.6
The broad expanse of water in this case may be a river or natural lake, and the Buckingham Palace identification is likely to remain speculative.
Read full Catalogue entry