Catalogue entry

T03064 A GARDEN 1869

Inscribed with Moore's anthemion device and the date ‘1869’ bottom left; inscribed on the stretcher ‘No 1/A GARDEN/A. Moore/3 Red Lion Square. W.C.’
Oil on canvas, 68 3/4 × 34 5/8 (174.5 × 88)
Purchased from Fischer Fine Art Ltd (Grant-in-Aid) with assistance from the Friends of the Tate Gallery 1980
Prov: ...; Alexander Henderson (later Baron Faringdon) by 1894 and sold by his executors, Sotheby's 13 June 1934 (123), bt Collings (£12); ...; acquired c.1970 from Jarl Johansson, Hälsingborg, Sweden by Vagn Laursen, Snekkersten, Denmark and from him, c.1971, by Steffen Irmang, sold Sotheby's Belgravia, 1 October 1979 (42, repr.in colour), bt Fischer Fine Art Ltd.
Exh: R.A. 1870 (966, ‘A garden’).
Lit: Alfred Lys Baldry, Albert Moore, 1894, pp.39–40, repr.facing p.20 as in the collection of Alexander Henderson.

'A Garden’ is one of Moore's earliest canvases of single, standing female figures in classical drapery, the first being ‘Azaleas’ which he exhibited in 1868 (Hugh Lane Municipal Gallery of Modern Art, Dublin; exh. Victorian High Renaissance, Manchester, Minneapolis and Brooklyn 1978–9, no.72, repr.). Other pictures in this vein are the smaller ‘Shuttlecock’ (Private Coll.; ibid., no.74, repr.) and ‘Battledore’ (Coll. Paul Johnson) of 1869–70 and such later works as ‘Blossoms’ of 1881 (Tate Gallery, N01549). Although depicting a nude figure, the ‘Venus’ of 1869 (York City Art Gallery; exh. Victorian High Renaissance, no.73, repr.) is also formally related to ‘A Garden’. In all these works Moore depicts a full-length figure standing in a shallow space which is closed by a high wall, screen or background curtain. A rectangle of paving or carpet at the bottom of the picture (often cut by the picture edge) helps to define this space but, because of the steep recession of its lines, also emphasises the picture surface. Pale colours and low-relief modelling serve the same end.

Moore's interest in painting these decorative canvases of full-length classical figures was probably stimulated by two mural schemes which he executed at Claremont in 1867 and the Queen's Theatre, Long Acre in 1868, the latter comprising a tempera frieze of life-size classical figures over the proscenium arch. He was also on friendly terms with Whistler at this time. While the latter adopted Moore's use of classical draperies, Moore took up Whistler's interest in Japanese prints. The pattern-making and soft colours of ‘A Garden’ can be partly attributed to this Japonisme.

Moore's intentions in the late 1860s appear to have been accurately summed up by Sidney Colvin who, writing in The Portfolio in 1870 (p.5), described Moore's ‘habit, right or wrong, of making the decorative aspect of his canvas, regarded as an arrangement of beautiful lines and refreshing colours, the one important matter in his work. The subject, whatever subject is chosen, is merely a mechanism for getting beautiful people into beautiful situations’. Some critics, however, had difficulty in making sense of Moore. Reviewing ‘A Garden’ when it was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1870, a writer in The Art-Journal (1870, p.171) found it ‘an anomaly, and perhaps an anachronism; in style it has no precise place in time or space: its nearest belongings would seem to be among the mural paintings of Pompeii; and yet the figure is so flat that the manner is rather that of a bas-relief than of a picture. In colour the artist has an unaccountable liking for washed-out greens and feeble, faded tones generally’.

Two cartoons for ‘A Garden’ are in the Victoria and Albert Museum: no. D251–1905, charcoal and white chalk on brown paper, 46 1/2 × 23 1/2in. (exh. Albert Moore and his Contemporaries, Laing Art Gallery, Newcastle 1972, no.28), showing the figure lightly draped but lacking the extremities of the limbs (either because the paper was too small originally or was later cut down), and no.250–1905, charcoal on brown paper, 62 × 34in., not available for inspection in 1982 but said to show the figure nude and to be pricked for transfer to the canvas.

A small drawing of the composition is in the Hunterian Art Gallery, University of Glasgow: black and white chalk on brown paper, 11 13/16 × 7in.; the figure is draped and a vase and a bowl are indicated at the bottom right, instead of the basket seen in the painting.

Moore moved to 3 Red Lion Square, the address given on the stretcher of ‘A Garden’, in 1869. The painter R.B. Martineau had formerly worked there.

Published in:
The Tate Gallery 1980-82: Illustrated Catalogue of Acquisitions, London 1984