J.M.W. Turner
Joseph Mallord William Turner Petworth House: Music in the White Library 1827
Joseph Mallord William Turner,
Petworth House: Music in the White Library
1827
Petworth House: Music in the White Library 1827
D22699
Turner Bequest CCXLIV 37
Turner Bequest CCXLIV 37
Gouache and watercolour on blue wove paper, 140 x 190 mm
Stamped in black ‘CCXLIV 37’ bottom right
Blind stamped with Turner Bequest monogram bottom right
Stamped in black ‘CCXLIV 37’ bottom right
Blind stamped with Turner Bequest monogram bottom right
Accepted by the nation as part of the Turner Bequest 1856
Exhibition history
1937
Watteau to Wilkie, British Museum, London, February 1937 (no catalogue, as ‘A Music Party at Petworth’).
1953
Display of Watercolours from the Turner Bequest, Tate Gallery, London, January 1953–April 1959 (no catalogue, as ‘Petworth: The Spinet Player’).
1957
Ann Lapraik Livermore, ‘Turner and Music’, Music and Letters, vol.38, no.2, April 1957, pp.174.
1963
Turner Watercolors from The British Museum: A Loan Exhibition Circulated by the Smithsonian Institution, National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC, September–October 1963, Museum of Fine Arts of Houston, Texas, November, M.H. de Young Memorial Museum, San Francisco, December 1963–January 1964, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, January–March, William Rockhill Nelson Gallery of Art, Kansas City, Missouri, March–April, Brooklyn Museum, New York, May, National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa, June–July 1964 (30).
1968
Bicentenary Exhibition 1768–1968, Royal Academy of Arts, London, December 1968–March 1969 (556B).
1970
Turner at Petworth: An Exhibition Arranged by the National Trust of Drawings of Petworth by J.M.W. Turner R.A. 1775–1851, Petworth House, Petworth, June–August 1970 (no catalogue).
1972
Das Aquarell 1400–1950, Haus der Kunst, Munich, October 1972–January 1973 (151).
1977
Turner Watercolors: An Exhibition of Works Loaned by The Trustees of the British Museum, International Exhibitions Foundation tour, Cleveland Museum of Art, September–November 1977, Detroit Institute of Arts, December 1977–February 1978, Philadelphia Museum of Art, March–April 1978 (33).
1979
Turner at Petworth, Petworth House, Petworth August–October 1979 (no catalogue).
1989
Turner and the Human Figure: Studies of Contemporary Life, Tate Gallery, London, April–July 1989 (58).
2002
Turner at Petworth, Petworth House, Petworth, July–September 2002 (47).
2015
Mr. Turner, Petworth House, Petworth, January–March 2015 (27, as ‘Music in the White Library’, 1827, reproduced in colour).
References
1909
A.J. Finberg, A Complete Inventory of the Drawings of the Turner Bequest, London 1909, vol.II, p.745, CCXLIV 37, as ‘The spinet player’.
1910
Alexander J. Finberg, Turner’s Sketches and Drawings, London 1910, p.128.
1939
Camille Mauclair, Turner, trans. Eveline Byam Shaw, London and Toronto 1939, p.159 reproduced.
1963
Edward Croft-Murray, Turner Watercolors from The British Museum: A Loan Exhibition Circulated by the Smithsonian Institution, exhibition catalogue, National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC 1963, no.30 as ‘Petworth, Music and Cards in the Library’.
1968
Graham Reynolds, Bicentenary Exhibition 1768–1968, exhibition catalogue, Royal Academy of Arts, London 1968, no.556B as ‘The Spinet Player, Petworth’.
1970
Lord Egremont and Kenneth Clark, Turner at Petworth: An Exhibition Arranged by the National Trust of Drawings of Petworth by J.M.W. Turner R.A. 1775–1851, exhibition catalogue, Petworth House, Petworth 1970.
1972
Walter Koschatzky, Herbert Pée, Dieter Kuhrmann and others, Das Aquarell 1400–1950, exhibition catalogue, Haus der Kunst, Munich 1972, no.151, p.107.
1975
Andrew Wilton, Turner in the British Museum: Drawings and Watercolours, exhibition catalogue, Department of Prints and Drawings, British Museum, London 1975, p.88 under no.129.
1977
Andrew Wilton, Turner Watercolors: An Exhibition of Works Loaned by The Trustees of the British Museum, exhibition catalogue, Cleveland Museum of Art 1977, no.33 reproduced as ‘Petworth: A Lady Playing the Spinet in the Library’.
1980
Pierre Rouve, Turner, étude de structures, Paris 1980, p.42 reproduced.
1982
Guy Weelan, J.M.W. Turner, trans. I. Mark Paris, New York 1982, pl.89, p.78.
1983
Patrick Youngblood, ‘Three Mis-Identified Works by J.M.W. Turner’, Burlington Magazine, vol.125, October 1983, pp.615, 616, 618, 619.
1987
Andrew Wilton, Turner in his Time, London 1987, pp.[170] pl.232, [171], 198.
1989
Ann Chumbley and Ian Warrell, Turner and the Human Figure: Studies of Contemporary Life, exhibition catalogue, Tate Gallery, London 1989, no.58 reproduced as ‘Music in the White Library, Petworth House’, p.54 under no.60, 55 under no.63.
1989
Martin Butlin, Mollie Luther and Ian Warrell, Turner at Petworth: Painter and Patron, London 1989, pp. 92, 142, 143, 159 pl.9.
1990
Martin Butlin, Mollie Luther and Ian Warrell, Turner: Les Années Egremont: Chefs d’oeuvre inédits, trans. Tamara Préaud, Paris 1990, pl.9.
1991
Ian Warrell, Turner: The Fourth Decade: Watercolours 1820–1830, exhibition catalogue, Tate Gallery, London 1991, p.60 under no.65.
1992
Joyce H. Townsend, ‘Turner Research Project: Information on Painting Materials via Standard Imaging Techniques’, Journal of Photographic Science, vol.40, 1992, p.64 fig.7, fig.8 [‘X-radiograph’] as ‘The Spinet Player’.
2002
Christopher Rowell, Ian Warrell and David Blayney Brown, Turner at Petworth, exhibition catalogue, Petworth House, Petworth 2002, pp.113 fig.110, 194 under no.47.
2004
Olivier Meslay, Turner: L’Incendie de la peinture, Découvertes Gallimard Arts, [Paris] 2004, p.41, 42 reproduced.
2005
Olivier Meslay, J.M.W. Turner: The Man Who Set Painting on Fire, trans. Ruth Sharman, London 2005, pp.41, 42, reproduced.
2006
Andrew Wilton, Turner in his Time, revised ed., London 2006, p.176, reproduced.
2013
Andrew Loukes in Jacqueline Riding and Loukes, Mr. Turner: an exhibition, exhibition catalogue, Petworth House, Petworth 2013, reproduced in colour p.20, pp.21, 32 no.27, as ‘CCLXIV’ 37, ‘Music in the White Library’, 1827).
Technique and condition
In this study the blue wove paper, typical of that used by Turner in his middle years, has been used as the background colour for one wall and the ceiling. It makes an equally significant optical contribution to all other areas as well, but has been so skilfully integrated that it mostly ‘reads’ as if it were light blue applied paint. The colours were applied very freely and rapidly, without even sketchy initial drawing.
This work is painted in small, rapid strokes of watercolour washes, and larger areas of gouache made by mixing lead white and the same range of pigments. None of the figures is detailed – indeed, the three seated nearest to the fireplace on the red wall are indicated by only a few small but telling strokes of flesh paint, with white gouache added to indicate highlights in their dress – yet they form a coherent impression of a group of individuals who could be counted readily.
All the gouache is made from lead white, a very opaque white pigment used by all oil painters at this period. Turner was an early user of lead white in gouache, and by the middle of the nineteenth century other artists were also using it regularly in this way. Lead white in scanty amounts of gum water as Turner used it, can easily discolour to a speckled or solid dark brown when it reacts with hydrogen sulphide gas, a common urban pollutant during the nineteenth century. Even minor or patchy discolouration would make this study distracting and difficult to understand, but here the gouache is in excellent condition. Nor have there been any tiny losses of material to reveal the blue paper beneath, which has occurred in quite a number of works where Turner used this material.
X-radiography of the paper indicates the presence of both the lead white, and vermilion. The vermilion is used full strength for the red wall, which makes it look opaque though it is used here as a true watercolour wash, and in the gouache for flesh tones. Vermilion is made from mercuric sulphide, and mercury is almost as X-ray opaque an element as lead. Chrome yellow, a pigment favoured by Turner at this period, would also show up readily in an X-radiograph due to its lead content, but was not found here. Instead he used yellow ochre and brown earth pigments, and their manufactured equivalent Mars orange for the orange shades, as well as a pure black pigment. The blue of the keyboard player’s dress is painted in ultramarine, a good choice since this pigment is sufficiently red in tone and brightly coloured when applied in gum water to contrast with the other blue areas represented by the blue paper.
Helen Evans
October 2008
Revised by Joyce Townsend
March 2011
How to cite
Helen Evans, 'Technique and Condition', October 2008, revised by Joyce Townsend, March 2011, in Elizabeth Jacklin, ‘Petworth House: Music in the White Library 1827’, catalogue entry, February 2019, in David Blayney Brown (ed.), J.M.W. Turner: Sketchbooks, Drawings and Watercolours, Tate Research Publication, November 2024, https://wwwThis is one of a large group of separate studies, most of which were made in gouache and watercolour on blue paper, associated with a visit to Petworth House in West Sussex, the home of the third Earl of Egremont. For more information, see the Introduction to this section.
The setting for this scene is Petworth’s White Library, a well-used drawing room in which guests gathered both before and after dinner; for more information about Turner’s numerous studies of this room, see the entry for Tate D22678 (Turner Bequest CCXLIV 16). Here, we see Lord Egremont’s guests socialising while a long-necked lady plays the pianoforte, watched by the woman on the left of the composition. While it is not possible to identify the piano player with any certainty, Christopher Rowell has noted the MP Thomas Creevey’s reminiscence that Lord Egremont’s daughter, Mrs King, took ‘to the piano forte after dinner’ during his 1828 visit to the house.1 If Charlotte King (1795–1870) also played during Turner’s 1827 visit she could be the woman seen here; however, another study of a woman at the pianoforte catalogued in this section certainly shows a different woman (see the entry for Tate D22701; Turner Bequest CCXLIV 39), meaning King could not have been the only evening pianist.
In addition to capturing the cheerful evening atmosphere, Turner also records the red of the painted walls, various items of comfortable looking furniture and the gilt surrounding the large mirror and the many framed paintings.
Verso:
Blank, save for inscriptions: inscribed in pencil ‘14 | l’ near centre; stamped in black with Turner Bequest monogram and ‘CCXLIV 37’ bottom left.
Elizabeth Jacklin
February 2019
How to cite
Elizabeth Jacklin, ‘Petworth House: Music in the White Library 1827’, catalogue entry, February 2019, in David Blayney Brown (ed.), J.M.W. Turner: Sketchbooks, Drawings and Watercolours, Tate Research Publication, November 2024, https://www