As Finberg observed, this is the origin of the view of this subject entitled ‘East Gate, Winchelsea’ in the
Liber Studiorum; for Turner’s drawing for the
Liber plate see Tate
D08167; Turner Bequest CXVIII M. Turner took another Winchelsea subject for the
Liber from folio 11 of this sketchbook (
D05762; Turner Bequest XCII 43), and as Gillian Forrester suggests, probably worked up the designs as a contrasting pair, pastoral in the present case and military in the other for which his working title was ‘Soldiers’.
Turner’s title for the
Liber plate based on the present drawing would indicate the Strand Gate leading into Winchelsea from the Rye road, the identification generally accepted today. However, the drawings and plates seem to show a different structure and surroundings. As discussed more extensively by Matthew Imms in his catalogue notes for the drawings made specifically for the
Liber, the gate lacks the round corner towers of the Strand Gate and looks more like the plainer Pipewell (or Land or Ferry) Gate at the top of Ferry Hill at the north-west corner of the town. Turner shows a windmill, probably St Leonard’s Mill that formerly stood on the hill of Iham; see also folio 4 (
D05722). More problematical is the tower at left of the gate, seen in folio 11 and in both
Liber plates, which cannot be accounted for today in relation to either the Pipewell or Strand Gates. It might indicate the castle said to have stood nearby or the remains of the church of St Leonard, now vanished but part of which was extant at least into the 1790s. The
Liber compositions are much romanticised while the supposedly on-the-spot drawings in the sketchbook might also contain some artistic licence.
