Henry Alexander Bowler

The Doubt: ‘Can these Dry Bones Live?’

exhibited 1855

Image released under Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND (3.0 Unported)

License this image

In Tate Britain

Walk Through British Art: 1840

Free entry

Artist: Henry Alexander Bowler 1824–1903
Medium: Oil paint on canvas
Dimensions: Support: 610 x 508 mm
frame: 788 x 685 x 100 mm
Collection: Tate
Acquisition: Presented by H. Archer Bowler 1921
Reference: N03592

Display caption

This young woman, leaning on the gravestone of a man called John Faithful, is contemplating religious doubt. In particular, the Christian belief that the dead will be resurrected on the Day of Judgement. Long-standing religious beliefs were being disrupted at the time this was painted. New scientific publications explored theories of evolution, challenging literal readings of the Bible. Her question appears to be answered by the growing chestnut tree and the stone at its base, carved with the word Resurgam’, which translates as ‘I shall rise again’. The blue butterfly on the skull symbolizes the human spirit.

Gallery label, August 2018

Does this text contain inaccurate information or language that you feel we should improve or change? We would like to hear from you.

Explore

architecture(42,290)
- religious(7,061)
  - church(4,545)
  - lich-gate(2)
- townscapes / man-made features(22,285)
  - graveyard(226)
  - path(407)
emotions, concepts and ideas(16,929)
- emotions and human qualities(5,367)
  - anxiety(1,031)
  - contemplation(146)
nature(46,522)
- animals: insects & lower animals(252)
  - butterfly(69)
- landscape(26,713)
  - wooded(8,610)
- weather(3,963)
  - sunshine(583)
- trees(3,336)
  - horse chestnut(2)
people(35,852)
- actions: postures and motions(9,287)
  - looking down(194)
- body(4,960)
  - bone(48)
  - skull(92)
- adults(23,437)
  - woman(9,319)
religion and belief(8,394)
- Judaeo-Christian imagery(858)
  - resurrection(30)
society(35,458)
- birth to death(1,461)
  - death(679)
symbols and personifications(7,286)
- religious(105)
  - Resurrection - butterfly(1)
- inscriptions(6,791)
  - Latin text(153)
objects(23,666)
- religious and ceremonial(1,737)
  - gravestone / tomb(326)

You might like

Robert Braithwaite Martineau, ‘Kit’s Writing Lesson’ 1852

Robert Braithwaite Martineau Kit’s Writing Lesson

1852

Robert Braithwaite Martineau, ‘The Last Day in the Old Home’ 1862

Robert Braithwaite Martineau The Last Day in the Old Home

1862

Frederic George Stephens, ‘Mother and Child’ c.1854

Frederic George Stephens Mother and Child

c.1854

On display at Tate Britain part of Walk Through British Art

James Collinson, ‘The Empty Purse (replica of ‘For Sale’)’ ?c.1857

James Collinson The Empty Purse (replica of ‘For Sale’)

?c.1857

Sir Edwin Henry Landseer, ‘Alexander and Diogenes’ exhibited 1848

Sir Edwin Henry Landseer Alexander and Diogenes

exhibited 1848

Richard Redgrave, ‘The Emigrant’s Last Sight of Home’ 1858

Richard Redgrave The Emigrant’s Last Sight of Home

1858

Abraham Solomon, ‘Not Guilty (The Acquittal)’ exhibited 1857

Abraham Solomon Not Guilty (The Acquittal)

exhibited 1857

Sir Edwin Henry Landseer, ‘A Dialogue at Waterloo’ exhibited 1850

Sir Edwin Henry Landseer A Dialogue at Waterloo

exhibited 1850

John Linnell, ‘Harvest Home, Sunset: The Last Load’ 1853

John Linnell Harvest Home, Sunset: The Last Load

1853

William Powell Frith, ‘The Derby Day’ 1856–8

William Powell Frith The Derby Day

1856–8

Robert Braithwaite Martineau, ‘Picciola’ 1853

Robert Braithwaite Martineau Picciola

1853

William Holman Hunt, ‘Our English Coasts, 1852 (‘Strayed Sheep’)’ 1852

William Holman Hunt Our English Coasts, 1852 (‘Strayed Sheep’)

1852

On display at Tate Britain part of Walk Through British Art

Henry Tanworth Wells, ‘Victoria Regina’ 1880

Henry Tanworth Wells Victoria Regina

1880

Abraham Solomon, ‘Waiting for the Verdict’ 1857

Abraham Solomon Waiting for the Verdict

1857

Philip Hermogenes Calderon, ‘Broken Vows’ 1856

Philip Hermogenes Calderon Broken Vows

1856