127. [N00492] Frosty Morning Exh. 1813
THE TATE GALLERY, LONDON (492)
Canvas, 44 3/4 × 68 3/4 (113·5 × 174·5)
Coll. Turner Bequest 1856 (8, ‘Frost Scene’ 5'9" × 3'9"); transferred to the Tate Gallery 1953.
Exh. R.A. 1813 (15); Turner's gallery 1835; Tate Gallery 1931 (57); Paris 1938 (141, repr.); New York, Chicago and Toronto 1946–7 (49, repr. pl. 40); Whitechapel 1953 (77); R.A. 1974 (18, repr.); R.A. 1974–5 (161, repr.); Leningrad and Moscow 1975–6 (16); Hamburg 1976 (22, repr.); Turner in Yorkshire, York City Art Gallery, June–July 1980 (34, repr.); Paris 1983–4 (22, repr. in colour); Birmingham 1984.
Lit. Thornbury 1862, i, pp. 170–71, 295; 1877, pp. 121–2, 431; Hamerton 1879, p. 149; Monkhouse 1879, p. 89; Bell 1901, pp. 63, 93 no. 128; Armstrong 1902, pp. 111–12, 222, repr. facing p. 112; Finberg 1910, pp. 61, 63–8; Whitley 1928, p. 211; Falk 1938, p. 43; Davies 1946, pp. 148–9, 185; Clare 1951, pp. 52–3, repr.; Finberg 1961, pp. 196, 229, 238, 252, 475 no. 183, pl. 15; Rothenstein and Butlin 1964, p. 27, pl. 51; Gage 1965, p. 79; Lindsay 1966, pp. 108, 114, 148; Lindsay 19662, p. 58; Brill 1969, pp. 14–15, repr.; R. B. Beckett (ed.), John Constable's Correspondence vi 1968, p. 21; Reynolds 1969, pp. 89–90, 106, colour pl. 67; Gaunt 1971, p. 6, colour pl. 13; Herrmann 1975, pp. 23, 229, colour pl. 58; Wilton 1979, p. 126, pl. 123; Gage 1980, pp. 64, 73, 290; David Hill, ‘A Frosty Morning: Turner in Yorkshire’, Country Life 25 December 1980, pp. 2402–3, pl. 5.
Exhibited with the following line:
‘The rigid hoar frost melts before his beam.’
According to the younger Trimmer the picture immortalised Turner's ‘old crop-eared bay horse, or rather a cross between a horse and a pony’. ‘The “Frost Piece” was one of his favourites ... He said he was travelling by coach in Yorkshire, and sketched it en route. There is a stage-coach in the distance that he was on at the time. My father told me that when at Somerset House [in the 1813 R.A. Exhibition] it was much brighter and made a great sensation ... The girl with the hare over her shoulders, I have heard my father say reminded him of a young girl whom he occasionally saw at Queen Anne-street [Turner's gallery], and whom, from her resemblance to Turner, he thought a relation. The same female figure appears in his “Crossing the Brook” [No. 130, N00497]]’ (Thornbury 1862, i, pp. 170–71). The reference to the girl is, as Lindsay has pointed out, to Evelina, one of Turner's two illegitimate daughters by the widow Sarah Danby. David Hill further suggests that the man with a gun is Walter Fawkes and the boy his son Hawkesworth. However, Turner would not have painted the figures, or indeed the landscape as a whole, on the spot and is more likely to have painted types, perhaps based on people he knew, rather than portraits. For Turner to combine a depiction of his best patron at the time with elements from his somewhat sub rosa private life seems highly unlikely.
The picture was praised in the Morning Chronicle for 3 May 1813 and, more significantly, by Constable's great patron Archdeacon Fisher who singled it out as the only picture to be preferred to Constable's in the exhibition: ‘But then you need not repine at this decision of mine; you are a great man like Buonaparte, and are only beaten by a frost’ (Beckett, loc. cit.).
In 1815 Ambrose Johns, arranging an exhibition in Plymouth, asked Turner to send this work and ‘Dido’ (probably No. 131 [N00498]; see Gage 1980, p. 64). However, Turner had already sent off Jason and Bligh Sands (Nos. 19 [N00471] and 87 [N00496]), writing of this picture, ‘The Frostpiece—I never thought of [?‘,’] as being generally wrong’ (letter of 4 November 1815, reprinted in Gage 1980, p. 64). In May 1818 Turner offered it to Dawson Turner for 350 guineas. Thornbury states that Trimmer's son had told him that Turner had once thought of giving the picture to Trimmer ‘who greatly prized it’. There is no evidence however that the picture ever left Turner's hands.
That the picture was on view in Turner's gallery in 1835 is attested by the account in the Spectator for 26 April: ‘We have seen Turner in cool and warm effects, and here we admire him also in a wintry scene. The hard frosty ground, the naked trees, the cold, dead, white sky, and the pale, weak, yellow gleam of sunlight, that scarcely relieves the cheerless desolation, or lessens the cold of the air, are imitated with the most delicate truth. Here are no raw white masses of snow and black branches, but the true tone of nature is imitated to perfection, for the picture conveys the feeling of the season.’
Claude Monet said of this picture, that it was ‘peint les yeux ouverts’ (George Moore, Vale, 1947, pp. 112–13, quoted in Gage, exh. cat., Paris 1983–4, p. 50).
Some of the glazes of this picture have been lost with time. There is also some old staining round the cracks in the sky, perhaps from early repainting.
Martin Butlin and Evelyn Joll, The Paintings of J.M.W. Turner, revised ed., New Haven and London 1984
- literature and fiction(3,170)
- work and occupations(14,297)