Skip navigation

Main menu

  • What's On
  • Visit
  • Art
    • Discover Art
    • Artists
    • Artworks
    • Stories
    Stories
    Stories

    Watch, listen and read

  • Learn
    • Schools
    • Tate Kids
    • Research
    • Activities and workshops
    Tate Kids
    Tate Kids

    Games, quizzes and films for kids

  • Shop
Become a Member
  • View All
  • Tate Modern
  • Tate Britain
  • Tate St Ives
  • Tate Liverpool
  • Exhibitions And Displays
  • On Today
  • Events
  • Tate Britain
    Tate Britain Free admission
  • Tate Modern
    Tate Modern Free admission
  • Tate Liverpool + RIBA North
    Tate Liverpool + RIBA North Free admission
  • Tate St Ives
    Tate St Ives Ticket or membership card required
  • Families
  • Accessibility
  • Schools
  • Private tours
  • Discover Art
  • Artists
  • Artworks
  • Stories
  • Schools
  • Tate Kids
  • Research
  • Activities and workshops
Tate Logo

Try searching for...

  • J.M.W. Turner
  • Ophelia
  • Tracey Emin

DON'T MISS

Exhibition

Turner & Constable: Rivals & Originals

Tate Britain
Until 12 Apr 2026
Exhibition

Theatre Picasso

Tate Modern
Until 12 Apr 2026
Become a Member
  • Research
  • Tate Papers
  • Tate Papers no.8

ISSN 1753-9854

Tate Papers no.8 Autumn 2007

The Autumn 2007 issue of Tate Papers, edited with the assistance of Bryony Bery, is given over to the papers produced for the Inherent Vice: The Replica and its Implications in Modern Sculpture Workshop, held at Tate Modern on 18–19 October 2007 and supported by The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation.

A significant purpose of gathering together different viewpoints and professions from around the world was to air the multi-disciplinary debate concerning decay and replication in relation to sculpture of the last hundred years, and to seek a deeper understanding of the, often difficult, problems that arise for the artists, their heirs and the collections that are custodians of their work. Therefore, we are pleased to publish here, with only limited changes and omissions, not only a range of short papers that were made available to participants prior to the workshop, but also a section of 'Afterthoughts', expressing the reflections of participants after the workshop.

We see these short papers as a beginning of an international and multi-disciplinary discussion that we hope will lead to a fuller airing of the issues in future workshops, conferences and publications.
Matthew Gale

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

In this Issue

The Modern Cult of Replicas: A Rieglian Analysis of Values in Replication

Sebastiano Barassi

Thoughts on Replication and the Work of Eva Hesse

Michelle Barger

Afterthoughts: Introduction

Matthew Gale

Amazement and Uneasiness: Early Thoughts

Matthew Gale

Anthony McCall’s Line Describing a Cone

Anthony McCall and Mark Godfrey

Authority and Ethics

Carol Mancusi-Ungaro

Blurring the Boundaries between Art and Life (in the Museum?)

Anna Dezeuze

Carl Andre

Alistair Rider

Degradation of Naum Gabo’s Plastic Sculpture: The Catalyst for the Workshop

Stephen Hackney

Digitisation and Conservation: Overview of Copyright and Moral Rights in UK Law

Tate Legal and Copyright Department

Gabo Cataloguing Project at the Tate Archive

Anna McNally

Hélio Oiticica

Guy Brett

Inherent Vice

Julian Stallabrass

Inherent Vice or Vice Versa

Sturtevant

Je travaille sur la présence

Didier Vermeiren

Kurt Schwitters: Reconstructions of the Merzbau

Karin Orchard

The Model of Vladimir Tatlin’s Monument to the Third International: Reconstruction as an Instrument of Research and States of Knowledge

Nathalie Leleu

Naum Gabo and the Quandaries of the Replica

Christina Lodder

Nothing but the Real Thing: Considerations on Copies, Remakes and Replicas in Modern Art

Lydia Beerkens

Participant Biographies

Posthumous Legal and Ethical Issues

Henry Lydiate

Reconstructing the Forgotten: An Exhibition of 1970s and 1980s Video Installations, Re-staged with Authentic Technology

Joanna Phillips

Replicas and Reconstructions in Twentieth-Century Art

Christiane Berndes

Replicas of Constructions by Naum Gabo: A Statement by the Copyright Holders

Graham Williams and Nina Williams

Replicas of László Moholy-Nagy’s Light Prop: Busch-Reisinger Museum and Harvard University Art Museums

Henry Lie

Replication and Decay in Damien Hirst's Natural History

Petra Lange-Berndt

Replication of Sculpture / Works of Art: Legal Guidelines

Tate Legal and Copyright Department

Replication: Some Thoughts, Some Works

Simon Starling

Replication: Then and Now

Penelope Curtis

Resistance to Replication

Margaret Iversen

Richard Serra: A Case Study

Lynne Cooke

Selected Bibliography

Should We Reproduce the Beauty of Decay? A Museumsleben in the work of Dieter Roth

Heide Skowranek

Tate Sculpture Replica Project

Lyndsey Morgan and Jackie Heuman

Terminology for Further Expansion

The Enduringly Ephemeral

Alex Potts

The Passing Away of Art

Ulrich Lang

The Rules of the Game

Walter Grasskamp

Thoughts on Thoughts on Replication

Harry Cooper

Why/Why Not Replicate?

Jennifer Mundy

Artwork
Close

Join in

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
Sign up to emails

Sign up to emails

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Tate’s privacy policy

About

  • About us
  • Our collection
  • Terms and copyright
  • Governance
  • Picture library
  • ARTIST ROOMS
  • Tate Kids

Support

  • Tate Collective
  • Members
  • Patrons
  • Donate
  • Corporate
  • My account
  • Press
  • Jobs
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Contact
© The Board of Trustees of the Tate Gallery, 2026
All rights reserved