Kunsthalle Mannheim (Mannheim, Germany): MOTHER!
- René Magritte 1898–1967
- Original title
- L'Esprit de géométrie
- Gouache on paper
- Support: 375 × 292 mm
frame: 555 × 455 × 35 mm
- Presented by the Hon. Ivor Montagu 1966
René Magritte 1898-1967
T00892 L'Esprit de la Géométrie
(The Spirit of Geometry) c.1936
Inscribed 'Magritte' b.r.
Gouache on paper, 14 3/4 x 11 1/2 (37.5 x 29)
Presented by Ivor Montagu 1966
Prov: Presented, probably by Magritte, to the Artists International Association to be sold in aid of Spanish relief; Ivor Montagu, Watford, Herts. 1937
Exh: René Magritte, Esher Surrey, The Hague, November-December 1936 (25) as 'Maternité' (watercolour); 1937 Exhibition - Unity of Artists for Peace, Democracy and Cultural Development, Artists International Association, 41 Grosvenor Square, London, April-May 1937 (605) as 'Maternity'
Lit: Louis Scutenaire, René Magritte (Brussels 1947), p.95
Repr: Simon Wilson, The Surrealists (London 1974), pl.4
A very similar gouache of the same theme - a mother holding a baby but with the heads interchanged - was shown in the Magritte exhibition at Notizie, Turin, in March-April 1965 (repr. in catalogue p.12) and subsequently passed through the hands of the Galerie La Boétie, New York. It is the same size as this work and resembles it very closely, the main differences being that the woman's hair is dark instead of fair and the child has some hair on its head instead of being completely bald. The colours are more or less the same.
The Tate's version formerly had a label on the backboard in the artist's handwriting inscribed 'René Magritte. Bruxelles | "Maternité"'. However, Magritte wrote to Luciano Pistoi of Notizie in 1965 that the work in his exhibition should be called not 'Maternity' but 'The Spirit of Geometry'. Mme Magritte confirms (letter of 19 November 1976) that her husband did not like the original title 'Maternity' and decided to change it to 'The Spirit of Geometry'.
David Sylvester has suggested that the Tate's gouache was probably the one exhibited at The Hague in November-December 1936 and that Magritte or Mesens gave it to the AIA a few weeks later to be sold in aid of Spanish relief, and Magritte then painted the other version as a replacement. Magritte was in London in February-March 1937, painting for Edward James. Various of the Magrittes exhibited at The Hague later turned up at the London Gallery, and it is possible that Magritte obtained this gouache from the London Gallery's stock with the promise to paint a further version.
Ronald Alley, Catalogue of the Tate Gallery's Collection of Modern Art other than Works by British Artists, Tate Gallery and Sotheby Parke-Bernet, London 1981, p.464, reproduced p.464